Skip to the stories
Electronics & Semiconductors

MoCA 2.5 Coax Coexistence With DOCSIS 3.1 and Satellite TV

  • Brian Dipert
  • 564 reads

MoCA 2.5 can share coax with DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite TV, but running all three at once runs out of spectrum. Here's how D-Band and Band E settings sort it out.

MoCA 2.5 Coax Coexistence With DOCSIS 3.1 and Satellite TV

You can run cable broadband, satellite TV, and a coax-based home network over the same wiring. Just not all three at the same time.

Brian Dipert, writing for EDN, has spent the last stretch of coverage digging into why his Comcast connection kept misbehaving, and DOCSIS 3.1 and MoCA 2.5 kept surfacing in that work. Now he's looking at the spectrum conflicts more broadly, including satellite. The coexistence problems are conceptually similar across all three services, but the details and the fixes differ.

MoCA generations and what changes between them

MoCA, the Multimedia over Coax Alliance standard, moves data between devices over existing coax. The peak bandwidth depends mostly on two things: the width of each channel and how many channels can be bonded together.

  • MoCA 1.x: 50 MHz per channel, one channel maximum, 175 Mbps maximum (carried over 100 Mbps Ethernet)
  • MoCA 2.0 and 2.1: 100 MHz per channel, two channels maximum, 1 Gbps maximum
  • MoCA 2.5: 100 MHz per channel, five channels maximum, 2.5 Gbps maximum

The jump to 2.5 Gbps comes from those extra three channels, but how they're placed in the spectrum is what creates trouble. MoCA 2.5's Band D is five 100 MHz channels spanning 1,125 to 1,675 MHz.

Where Band D collides with DOCSIS 3.1

DOCSIS 3.0 and MoCA 2.5 sit comfortably side by side. There's a 123 MHz guard band between them, so nothing overlaps. DOCSIS 3.1 is a different story. It extends up to 1,218 MHz, and some service providers push it higher, which puts it directly on top of MoCA 2.5's lower channels.

The fix is conceptually simple: stop MoCA from transmitting in the overlapping range by disabling one or more of its channels. DOCSIS 3.1 keeps its full performance potential without interference, and the cost is lower peak MoCA bandwidth.

Band D subsets and their trade-offs

Most MoCA adapters let you pick one of a few operating modes rather than mixing and matching channels freely:

  • D-Band High: 1,350–1,675 MHz, a 325 MHz wide, three-channel connection
  • D-Band Low: 1,125–1,225 MHz, a 100 MHz wide, single-channel connection
  • D-Band Extended (default): 1,125–1,675 MHz, all five channels

Between the two reduced modes sits a 125 MHz guard band, from 1,225 to 1,350 MHz. That unused slice could free up room for DOCSIS 3.1 Extended deployments. It also happens to contain the 23-centimeter Amateur Radio band, which spans 1,260–1,270 MHz, so it's another possible interference source to keep in mind.

In the adapters Dipert has found, you can run only one of D-Band Low, D-Band High, or D-Band Extended at a time. You can't enable Low and High together. Some models also expose a user-configurable Lowest Operating Frequency (LOF) setting.

Two adapters only see each other if they match. Their D-Band mode and LOF setting have to be identical, and so does the encryption password if one is in use. That password is often disabled by default, so it's worth checking.

D-Band High is the easy one to understand. It keeps MoCA out of both the 23-centimeter ham band and the bulk of DOCSIS 3.1 use. D-Band Low is less obvious. Its footprint overlaps DOCSIS 3.1 more, and its single channel tops out at half a gigabit. One plausible use is a MoCA channel that the provider uses to monitor and maintain the modem or gateway, out of the end user's reach. Dipert points to a second possibility that end users can actually take advantage of, which I'll come back to.

Why a MoCA filter belongs inside your network too

Most people know about MoCA filters at the point of entry (PoE), where they stop your in-home MoCA traffic from leaking onto the provider's shared plant and stop neighbors' traffic from reaching you. That's the standard role.

Depending on whether your MoCA network runs in D-Band Extended, D-Band High, or Band E, you may also need a filter inside the home, right before the cable modem's coax connector. Cable modems are built to work with many providers and service tiers. Even if your provider doesn't use spectrum above 1,002 MHz, as was the case with Dipert's Comcast service, the modem can still be sensitive to MoCA energy above that line. Without a filter, that interference can degrade modem performance across the board.

Band E and the satellite TV problem

Satellite TV overlaps MoCA differently. The relevant range is L-band, from 0.95 to 2.15 GHz. That band carries intermediate-frequency signals from a satellite dish's low-noise block (LNB) downconverter to the indoor receivers over coax. It's also used by weather satellites, GPS/GNSS, and mobile satellite services.

Running MoCA 2.5 in any Band D mode over that same coax would cause destructive interference that hits both the satellite and the MoCA network. The workaround is Band E, which moves MoCA below 1 GHz, typically starting at 400 MHz and running up to about 700 MHz.

One Kiwee Broadband adapter goes further, operating in Band E Extended up to 900 MHz. That gives it full five-channel, 2.5 GbE capability, plus dual concurrent Ethernet ports. The same manufacturer's other adapters use Band D instead, and some adapters from other vendors let you choose between Band D and Band E.

Running more than one MoCA network

Since matching settings define a network, you can run several MoCA networks over the same coax, as long as they don't overlap each other or whatever else is active on the line, such as DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite. Set every adapter in network one identically, and every adapter in network two differently.

If MoCA is the only thing on the coax, three distinct networks are possible: one in D-Band Low, one in D-Band High, and one in Band E. That's a clever way to get separate logical networks on one cable plant, though the spectrum runs out quickly once anything else is added.

Why all three services together don't fit

Satellite TV providers rarely sell their own internet service. Geostationary (GEO) satellite links have slow speeds and high latency, so providers usually team up with other broadband companies. DSL, fiber, and cellular all pair fine with satellite TV. Cable is the awkward one.

Add cable broadband and satellite TV to the same coax, and there's no spectrum left for MoCA unless you run separate coax topologies throughout the house. Dipert also notes the practical reality that a cable provider would rather bundle broadband with TV for you. LEO satellite internet may change the picture as it matures, but for now, this is the trade-off to plan around.

The practical takeaway: pick the two services you need on coax, set MoCA to the band that stays clear of them, and add filters where the modem or the neighborhood needs protection. The MoCA 2.5 adapter teardown and its hardware configuration switches should show how that selection works at the board level.

Source: Brian Dipert · www.edn.com

From the same set